PastSmallTalk
Back to games

How to Play Would You Rather

Two choices. One pick. Quickly discover where you disagree.

How the game works

  1. Read both options

    Each question gives you two choices—Option A and Option B. Read them both out loud. No hedging: you have to pick one, even if both options are awful.

  2. Pick one

    Decide which you'd rather do. No "it depends"—commit to A or B.

  3. Explain why

    Share your reasoning. That's where the conversation happens. You'll learn each other's priorities, quirks, and maybe a few surprises.

What you'll see

Play example game

Example options

  • Eat 12 donuts in one sitting — or eat 200 donuts over a week.
  • Giant house no garden — or small house with a giant garden.
  • Unlimted salsa but no chips — or unlimited chips but no salsa.

Hidden features

  • Click the speaker on any question to have a voice narrate it out for your group.
  • Duplicate a game to adjust the questions to your vibe.
  • Make any game private to keep it just for you.

Playing tips

  • Try a speed round for a light, silly game.
  • Disagreeing is good. It sparks conversation.
  • Describe what your life would be like with each option.
Start a free game

No sign-up. Pick a curated game and play.